Introduction
Indian judge Dalveer Bhandari of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) decided in favour of fresh interim remedies mandating Israel to immediately stop its military activities in the southern Gaza region of Rafah. The governorate's border crossing had to be opened by the court to facilitate the immediate delivery of supplies. The purpose of this action is to handle the humanitarian situation and guarantee that the impacted population receives the necessary supplies. The International Court of Justice's decision highlights how important it is to facilitate humanitarian aid and how concerned the international community is about the safety of people in crisis areas. Along with most justices, Justice Dalveer Bhandari had called on Russia to immediately stop its military activities in Ukraine. Justice Bhandari supported the majority in the 13-2 ruling in 2022, with the Chinese and Russian justices voting against it.
Thirteen judges voted in favour of the ruling, and two against. Along with Justice Bhandari, American Judge Sarah Cleveland also voted in favour of ending Israel's military action in Rafah. The only two judges who dissented from the decision were retired Israeli judge Aharon Barak and Ugandan judge Julia Sebutinde. According to Gaza's civil defence organization, overnight Israeli bombings in Rafah have left forty Palestinian refugees dead after their tents were set ablaze. The Arab world has condemned the attack.
About Justice Dalveer Bhandari
Famous Judgement of Justice Dalveer Bhandari
Israel and Gaza War
At least 5,000 rockets fired by Hamas against Israel were launched from Gaza on October 7, 2023. Approximately 1400 Israelis were murdered in this, along with other Israeli troops and civilians—including women and children—who were kidnapped and carried to the Gaza Strip. A day later, Israel declared war on Hamas and carried out retaliation attacks. Approximately 2700 Palestinians had died and one million had been internally displaced as of October 15. Israel cut off Gaza's supply of gasoline, food, water, and power, which precipitated a serious humanitarian catastrophe in the area. While Hamas has urged the people of Northern Gaza to remain put, Israel has advised them to leave the area. Additionally, Israel and Hezbollah exchanged gunfire when Hezbollah terrorists launched missiles into Israel from Lebanon, to which Israel retaliated with airstrikes in Lebanon.
Israel's attack on Gaza has resulted in at least 35,984 Palestinian deaths and up to 80,643 injuries since October 7. 1,139 people have died in Israel as a result of Hamas's strike on that date, and many more are currently in detention.
The Israeli bombings that burned the tents of Palestinian refugees in Rafah overnight have left forty dead, according to Gaza's civil defence organization on Monday. The attack was denounced by the Arab world.
The Israeli army said that two top Hamas operatives had been killed in late Sunday airstrikes, hours after a missile attack on Tel Aviv, and that it was looking into claims of people being killed in a fire.
Strong protests were launched by Egypt, Jordan, Kuwait, and Qatar in response to the Israeli bombardment, and the latter country warned that it may "hinder" efforts to resume the ceasefire and hostage-release negotiations that had been put on hold since October 7.
"The massacre committed by the Israeli occupation army in the refugee tents northwest of Rafah city in the southern Gaza Strip has left 40 martyrs and 65 wounded," stated agency spokesman Mohammad al-Mughayyir.
Israel invaded Gaza in late October, but its ground forces are still engaged in combat with Hamas in Rafah and in the northern and centre regions where Hamas has reorganized.
The United States, Israel's greatest friend, has pushed all parties to pick up the cease-fire negotiations, and in recent days, efforts have been made to start new negotiations with US, Egyptian, and Qatari mediators.
The two parties are at odds on a variety of topics.
On March 25, 2024, the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) firmly called for an "immediate ceasefire" in the ongoing battle in Gaza, marking a significant development following more than five months of nonstop fighting. Amidst mounting tensions and humanitarian concerns, the resolution emphasised the pressing necessity of ending the hostilities that have afflicted the region, causing great suffering to civilians and worsening an already grave humanitarian crisis.
Notably, the UNSC added a critical humanitarian component to the resolution by demanding the release of all captives held by Hamas in addition to calling for a truce. In addition to putting an end to the bloodshed, this multipronged strategy addressed the condition of people who had been wrongfully imprisoned and emphasised the significance of respecting international law and human rights in times of war.
Conclusion
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) position that Justice Dalveer Bhandari holds demonstrates his commitment to humanitarian ideals and international law. His recent vote in support of temporary measures to stop Israeli military operations in Rafah and allow humanitarian supplies to enter the border emphasizes how important it is to solve humanitarian crises and guarantee civilian safety in areas of conflict. This choice is consistent with his respect for the rule of law and human rights, as demonstrated by his participation in the ICJ finding against Russia's military activities in Ukraine.
With deep historical, geographical, and political origins, the current confrontation between Israel and Gaza, which has resulted in numerous fatalities and a dire humanitarian situation, is still a very complicated matter. The terrible bombs in Rafah and other recent escalations have prompted universal outrage and brought attention to the pressing need for international engagement and peace initiatives. To address the humanitarian crisis and provide the circumstances for a long-term solution, the UN Security Council's demand for an immediate ceasefire and the release of captives is essential.
The efforts of Justice Bhandari and the response of the world community to the Gaza conflict demonstrate a wider dedication to respecting human rights and offering assistance during emergencies. His legal work continues to advocate for a society where justice and humanitarian ideals are paramount, and it has an impact on worldwide legal norms.
Reference
